Located at 4559 Queen Street in Niagara Falls, Poptones was more than a record store, much more. It existed for a decade, the 19’80s and ’90s, and was the coolest store I ever visited. That includes the giant record stores of lore on Yonge Street in Toronto, the fantastic ones in Detroit, and even Amoeba Music in Berkeley, California. Poptones was definitely a destination, but unlike most Niagara Falls attractions, it had nothing to do with the Falls, cheesy Clifton Hill, or honeymoons.
Poptones was owned by the uber-cool, yet mysterious Frank, a person who remains in the minds and hearts of all of us who remember Poptones so fondly.

I grew up in St. Catharines, about a half-hour drive from Niagara Falls. As a high school “student” in the late 80s, a bunch of us would drive down to Poptones on Friday nights and hang out until it closed at midnight.
I still have 6 plastic bags with the Poptones logo and contact information printed proudly, which just proves that being a packrat isn’t entirely a bad thing. Some of the bags have yellow scotch tape stains around the handle because Frank would tape bags shut to prevent shoplifting. Below, I will discuss some of the records that I remember those bags holding.
What set Poptones apart was its owner, Frank.

While other record stores had better prices and more convenient locations, Poptones had Frank. While other stores had discount bins that allowed cheapskates and broke people to discover interesting music on the cheap, so long as you didn’t mind bible verses printed on the inner sleeves of the records, Poptones had Frank.
And sure, there was that record store on Bloor Street across from Lee’s Palace that was part thong shop and had an entire wall dedicated to displaying the risque underwear that was going to destroy western civilization, but Poptones had Frank!
Part Dude Lebowski, part Serpico, and part Tommy Chong, Frank was the guy at the party that everyone wanted to talk to. He had an intense charisma, familiar yet mysterious. For most people, it was “friends at first sight” with Frank.
Now that I think about it, Frank had some similarities to Harvey Keitel, too, specifically Keitel’s character, Augustus “Auggie” Wren, in the 1995 movie Smoke.
Eclectic records were de rigueur at Poptones.
While it was the 80s, people didn’t go to Poptones to pick up Bruce Springsteen, Cyndi Lauper, or Billy Idol records. Buying a mainstream record at Poptones would be the musical equivalent of buying a red MAGA hat at the Lincoln Memorial.

Looking towards the back of Poptones, there were bongs and t-shirts on the rightside wall, and on the left were the record bins. Back in those days, people wore t-shirts with giant faces of famous people printed on them. You’ve seen them, you’ve hated/had them: Charles Manson and Marilyn Monroe were common.
I once asked Frank if he had any with Molly Ringwald on them, and he got a laugh out of that: “Nobody has asked for that one before!”
I was recently reminded by a Facebook post that there was a table at the front of the store with business cards and flyers for raves. There were likely political flyers as well.
I can’t remember if there was a cat that would sleep on top of the records, but I don’t think there was.
Records I bought at Poptones.
The records that a record store sells probably say the most about the store, so let’s talk about them. Some of the records I remember buying at Poptones include:
Kill Ugly Pop – Leatherface Gets Religion (The Story So Far…)
I bought this on the strength of the jacket. The band’s name is intriguing (a band of Iggy Pop haters?, and the concept of Leatherface from Texas Chainsaw Massacre finding religion is wonderfully perverse. The album is actually pretty good, and has some songs that had my friend Roger and me singing along with “Gotta, gotta, gotta, gotta, gotta get a gun tonight.” (Full disclosure: the most lethal gun I have fired is a leaky water pistol.)

The band is from the UK, but to my ears, the music sounds like something from the backwoods of the US South. Imagine Jon Spencer Blues Explosion meets the feeling of Deliverance, the classic Burt Reynolds movie.
Tim Yohannan namedropped The Cramps, Birthday Party, and Naked Raygun in a brief 1984 review in MaximumRockandRoll.
Kill Ugly Pop remains pretty much a mystery, with not even the mighty KEXP able to shine much light on them: “And we may never know much more about KUP (unless Reverend U’Tang finds this post and decides to comment).”
Live Skull – Don’t Get Any on You
On my first trip to New York City, I lucked out and got to see Flipper at Irving Plaza. Also on the bill were Die Kreuzen and Live Skull. Part of the NY noise band scene, Live Skull were closer to Swans than they were Sonic Youth. They kind of have a wall of sound, and I really liked the “feel” of the music.

When I saw this album at Poptones, I had to have it. I wanted to relive seeing them live. It’s not bad, but one has to be in the mood for Live Skull. They do a great cover of the Curtis Mayfield classic “Pusherman,” which Ice-T also sampled/covered to great effect around the same time on I’m Your Pusher.
Michelle, my late wife was a big fan of Ice-T and got to say hello to him at the first Lollapalooza. She also had a lot of fun with the line “Out here on the street and don’t know what time it is!“
Frank was impressed when I paid for it: “I didn’t know you guys were into Live Skull!”

Foetus is the work of one man, Australian J. G. Thirlwell. The name gets a lot of attention, and a lot of revulsion. Thirlwell uses the name Foetus in various forms, going for maximum shock early on with You’ve Got Foetus on Your Breath, Scraping Foetus Off the Wheel, etc. Some of Thirlwell’s Foetus work is highly acclaimed, with the album Nail receiving 5-star ratings and reaching #1 in the UK indie chart.
While “just” an EP, this offering from Thirlwell clocks in at over 25 minutes. It more than held my interest then, and it stands the test of time. “I ought to scatter your brains from here to White Plains” alone was worth whatever I paid for this record.
The Feederz – Teachers in Space
I first learned of The Feederz from reading that stalwart of excellent journalism, Weekly World News. The World’s Only Reliable News ran a story about The Feeders that I will forever remember. It was below the fold, but on page 3, bottom right. The article described the band’s frontman, Frank Discussion, and how he would put two-sided tape on his forehead, then place live insects on the tape before going on stage.

The Feederz were anarchists, and their first album, Ever Feel Like Killing Your Boss?, was covered with sandpaper, the idea being that it would destroy the jackets of any records the Feederz came into contact with. I thought that was hilarious and unique, but later learned that other bands did it first, including UK band The Durutti Column in 1980. The band takes their name from a 6,000-member anarchist military column active during the Spanish Civil War, 1936-37. I later also learned that D. H. Peligro of Dead Kennedys, my favourite band, was the on-again/off-again drummer for The Feederz.
Teachers in Space features a famous image of the space shuttle exploding on the cover. It was the first shuttle mission to have a teacher on board. When I saw it at Poptones, I had to have it.
Frank wasn’t working the counter when I paid for this album. The young student who was writing the receipt was unfamiliar with the record. He refused to say the band’s name or the album’s name, instead asking, “Which one is the band?” as he motioned to both Feederz and Teachers in Space. Mission accomplished, Mr. Discussion.

Public Image Limited – Happy?
I can’t remember why I bought this record. Probably because I loved PiL’s previous offering, album (also known as Compact Disc, Cassette, or mp3, depending on the format). Oh well, at least my “mainstream” purchase was from the band that created the song for which Poptones is named.
Seattle was the single, and it is a pretty good song. Check it out.
Buffalo Bills fans take note: The Bruce Smith who plays drums on this album is NOT the NFL Hall of Famer.
Whatever happened to Frank, owner of Poptones?
After Poptones closed, there were a few fun rumours about the whereabouts of Frank. It was still the pre-Internet age, so rumours abounded. They were fun rumours, and because of Frank’s persona, they were believable rumours!

Here are the ones I heard/remember:
- Frank relocated to somewhere in the Southwest US, joining a cult led by Jane’s Addiction frontman Perry Farrell.
- Something to do with Thee Temple ov Psychick Youth (TOPY), the Genesis P-Orridge fellowship and chaos magic network (cult/fan group)
- Frank moved to Washington DC to work with PETA.
- I also read that Frank got busted for selling bootlegs in the early days of Poptones and was fined $25,000. That sounds probably considering how things work in Canada, but I would also think that a $25K fine would have been the end of Poptones.
Poptones research in the AI era
Poptones was not a global behemoth like Tower Records or HMV. Even in the part of Ontario known as Niagara, one had to be part of the “in crowd” to know about Poptones. Everyone in Canada would know Sam the Record Man, but Poptones?
Still, though, I “knew” that research using Google would reveal a lot, and if not, then ChatGPT/Gemini would reveal all. I knew WRONG.
Gemini even gave me disturbing information that, fortunately, turned out to be a hallucination:
“To those who frequented his shops, the man behind the counter was Frank Manley. Frank Manley passed away in August 2012.”
AI may have been confusing “Poptones Frank” with Frank Manley, an author who documented the Yorkville Music Scene in the 60s. Yorkville is now an extremely upscale shopping enclave in Toronto, but apparently it was an oasis for folk singers, hippies, uber hippy Neil Young, and, oddly, Rick James back in the “dope is a panacea, and bathing is an enemy” days.
Persistence pays off: Frank is found. Sort of.
I finally stumbled across a February 10, 2014, article in the Fort Erie Times that revealed that Frank’s actual last name is Florio. He also opened a small shop named after a Captain Beefheart song (Apes Ma) after Poptones (named after a PiL song) closed.
Apes Ma the store was tiny (5-feet wide), and Apes Ma the song is just 40 seconds long, so I guess Frank put 2 and 2 together and got the name.
I reached out to the author of the article, but did not receive a response, and a Google search on “Frank Florio” revealed nothing related to Poptones Frank.

PLEASE comment if you have memories of Frank or Poptones, and PLEASE let me know if I have made any mistakes in this post.
Thanks!


































